Skip to content
Best Custom Screens vs Home Depot 

Best Custom Screens vs Home Depot 

Who is the winner? The result will shock you!

The purpose of this article is to conduct an objective and detailed analysis between Best Custom Screens vs Home Depot, we will explore a variety of critical factors. The results will shock you! The analysis includes the diversity and quality of their product offerings, the level of customer service provided, the range and flexibility of customization options available, the pricing structure, and the overall customer experience. This analysis aims to highlight the unique strengths and advantages of Best Custom Screens in these areas, providing a clear and evidence-based comparison.

Los Angeles Screens with Dr Rubber Toe behind Tahoe Screen Door

What is the company Best Custom Screens?

1Best Custom Screens is a company that specializes in providing custom-made window and door screens. It is closely associated with Steve Tristan, an expert in the field of screen manufacturing and installation. Steve Tristan’s Best, as it’s often referred to, emphasizes Tristan’s significant involvement and expertise in the business, highlighting his commitment to quality and customer satisfaction. The company offers a variety of screen products, including options for sliding screen doors, window screens, and other related products, often tailored to individual customer needs and preferences.

What is Home Depot?

2Home Depot is a large American home improvement retailer known for offering a wide range of products and services for home improvement, construction, and gardening. They sell tools, construction products, and services, and are well-known for their large warehouse-style stores. Home Depot caters to both do-it-yourself customers and professional contractors.

From inside the Home Depot Screen Doors
From inside the Home Depot Screen Doors

Summary of Pros and Cons of Home Depot vs Best Custom Screens

HD Pros HD ConsBCS ProsBCS Cons
Wide selectionLimited selection on high end productsSpecialized selectionLead Time
Low pricesVery high price on custom itemsLow priceShipping Cost
In stock availabilityIf custom made available then very high costCustom availableNo in stock items
Physical storesCustomizing unavailable onlineOnline storeNo physical stores
Returns & ExchangesHave to wait in line to returnCustom sizes can be cut & training availableDo it yourself or send back 
In store employeesLimited knowledgeSteve Tristan’s BestOnline only

Outline of the Pro & Cons between Best Custom Screens vs Home Depot

Home Depot Pros
  • Wide selection – Home Depot has a vast range of home improvement products, including screens if you plan making them yourself. 
  • Low prices – Home Depot is very competitive for their in store products because of the volume they sell. 
  • In stock availability – Sliding Screen Doors sold are in stock but are limited in size to the 6 ft tall screen doors.
  • Returns & exchanges – You may return any stock item to Home Depot.
  • In store employees
Home Depot Cons
  • Limited selection on high end products – You cannot pick up a custom screen door or window screen in the store at Home Depot. 
  • Very high price on custom items – The price for a custom sliding screen door purchased thru Home Depot to be built at the manufacturer is upwards $800. 
  • Customizing unavailable online
  • Will need to wait in line to return – as well as there are limitations and rules that must be followed. In other words, don’t use a tool or item and then return. It’s not a free rental. 
  • Limited knowledge – Many employees at the Home Depot may have some knowledge but are not specialized. 
93 x 94 sliding screen door lowe's & home depot sliding screen doors
93 x 94 sliding screen door lowe’s & home depot sliding screen doors
Best Custom Screens Pros
  • Specialized selection – Best Custom Screens is limited to selling screening products and window coverings. All screens are custom made to size. If you know how to measure then all you need to do is order it. No need cutting and making yourself. 
  • Low price – Best Custom Screens is able to offer competitive prices comparable when you are comparing apples to apples products. 
  • Custom sizes available – Sliding Screen Doors are all custom made to size. Plus 6 ft and 8 ft tall screen doors are available. 
  • Easy to order online store – Place your order online and it arrives at your door. Nationwide shipping.
  • Products can be cut down – In the even you measured wrong. BCS can help you get it cut down by showing your tutorials that will show you how easy it is. 
  • How to training available – DIY and How to training available on the website or on the YouTube Channe
  • Steve Tristan’s Best – Go to the YouTube channel to get the latest how to and DIY tips. Meanwhile you may learn how to be a man too!
Best Custom Screens Cons
  • Longer lead time – Custom products do take longer to make in the factory. Expect 5 to 15 business days for custom items to be made.
  • Shipping cost – Shipping fully assembled screen doors can get very expensive to ship via freight or common carrier across the nation. It is only affordable to ship to the Western United States. The East Coast Fully Assembled Screen Doors cannot be shipped by UPS or Fedex. Therefore it is recommended ordering screen door kits for nationwide orders.
  • In stock items not available – It’s a challenge to keep in stock items that are sold in 1/16” increments.  Custom is exactly what it means, they are made to measure items. 
  • No physical stores – There are 4 shipping locations where our screens are made and shipped from.  
  • Do it yourself or send it back – Now you are working like a handyman.
  • Online only – Can’t go out shopping. Maybe it’ll save you money.
Shop for Sliding Screen Doors today made easy

Best Custom Screens sells a lot of sliding screen doors

Best Custom Screens sells a lot of sliding screen doors primarily due to their commitment to offering high-quality, durable products that meet a variety of customer needs. Their sliding screen doors are not only designed to fit a wide range of door sizes and types, but they also feature robust materials that ensure longevity and resistance to wear and tear. Additionally, Best Custom Screens emphasizes customer satisfaction by providing customizable options, allowing customers to choose from different styles, colors, and features to match their home décor and personal preferences. The company’s excellent customer service, combined with an easy online ordering process, further enhances the customer experience, leading to higher sales. Moreover, their competitive pricing and periodic promotions make their sliding screen doors an attractive choice for homeowners looking to enhance their living spaces with functional and aesthetically pleasing solutions.

3Home Depot – My experience in the store when trying to buy a screen door

My personal experience with Home Depot

I personally do not like going to Home Depot anymore unless I have to. I don’t have any reason other than Lowe’s Home Improvement is closer. But it also may be because I find that our nearest Home Depot location doesn’t have the best employees. I have continued to run into times where their knowledge is lacking, their enthusiasm in their jobs is lacking. Basically they aren’t very friendly. 

In addition, I had a time where we needed to buy some lumber. Alot of it. An entire pallet we need brought down from the top shelf and loaded into my truck.  The guys operating the forklift and the other guy who guided him and blocked off the walkway, were both totally high on marijuana. They were so high and acting very ignorant, that I almost walked out. I didn’t because every other home improvement store for miles did not have the wood I needed. I was afraid these guys were going to kill someone, including me. So I kept my distance. I would never have thought that the manager there would put up with that, but I guess these days with it being legal it must be difficult for good managers to do their job with idiots like this.

Online Review of HD

I also found this review around the same time I was there:  “Luis and his team of supervisors are so lazy. My friend needed something unlocked, and 3 employees were sitting having fun at being careless. It took them more than 10 minutes to get help after my friend requested again. Then Luis said to my friend that he couldn’t answer his questions although he never said that he had a question. He only needed help to open the locker. And still yet Luis kept repeating the same sentence that he doesn’t know anything about the items. When I wanted to complain, he said that he was one of the supervisors. The other employees who were sitting were supervisors as well. It looks like Home Depot is going to fall apart by this kind of management.”

Steve Tristan, Steve Tristan’s Best YouTube Channel


While The Home Depot offers a wide range of products and the convenience of a large-scale operation, Best Custom Screens appears to excel in specialized areas, particularly in custom screen solutions. Their focus on tailored products, expert advice, and personalized customer service positions them as a preferable choice for customers seeking specialized screen products and services. This niche focus and dedication to customer-specific needs give Best Custom Screens a distinctive edge in this comparison. In this analysis of Best Custom Screens vs Home Depot, we did our best to give any preferential treatment for either company. Rather we preferred to show the best of both companies, including the little problem Steve had with Home Depot.

As it states on the Home Depot about us page:

4The dream of creating a comprehensive shopping destination for DIY enthusiasts materialized with the opening of the inaugural Home Depot stores on June 22, 1979, in Atlanta, Georgia. These pioneering stores, each spanning roughly 60,000 square feet, were significantly larger than their competitors and offered an impressive range of 25,000 products, far exceeding the inventory of typical hardware stores of the era.

Fast forward to today, and The Home Depot has evolved into the world’s premier home improvement retailer. It employs roughly 475,000 dedicated associates, known for their distinctive orange spirit, and operates over 2,300 stores across the U.S., Canada, and Mexico. Modern Home Depot stores are expansive, averaging 105,000 square feet of indoor retail space. They are complemented by a robust e-commerce platform, providing a vast array of over one million products. This online presence caters not only to DIY enthusiasts and professional contractors but also supports the industry’s most extensive installation services for customers preferring a complete solution.

Unveiling the Ultimate Screen Showdown: Best Custom vs Home Depot

When it comes to upgrading your home with new screens, two prominent players stand out in the market: Best Custom Screens and Home Depot. Choosing the right screens can significantly impact the comfort and aesthetics of your living space. In this comprehensive product comparison, we’ll review and compare screens from both Best Custom Screens and Home Depot to help you make an informed decision.

The Contenders

Best Custom Screens

Best Custom Screens is a company that specializes in crafting custom-made window and door screens. They are known for their commitment to quality and personalized customer service. Best Custom Screens offers a variety of screen products, including options for sliding screen doors, window screens, and more, all tailored to individual customer needs and preferences. Their emphasis on customization and customer satisfaction sets them apart.

Home Depot

Home Depot, on the other hand, is a renowned home improvement retailer offering a wide range of products and services for home improvement, construction, and gardening. While they have a diverse selection of screens, they cater to both do-it-yourself customers and professional contractors. Home Depot is known for its vast network of warehouse-style stores and competitive pricing.

The Showdown: A Detailed Comparison

To help you evaluate the screens from Best Custom Screens and Home Depot, let’s dive into a detailed comparison across various key factors:

Factors to consider between Best Custom Screens and Home Depot


Product Diversity

Best Custom Screens excels in offering custom-made screens tailored to individual needs. In contrast, Home Depot provides a broader range of screens for various purposes, catering to a wider customer base.


Best Custom Screens places a strong emphasis on high-quality materials, ensuring durability and longevity. Home Depot offers screens with varying quality levels, depending on the specific product you choose.

Customization Options

For those seeking customization, Best Custom Screens is the clear winner, offering highly customizable screens to match your preferences. Home Depot, while versatile, has limited customization options for some products.


Both Best Custom Screens and Home Depot offer competitive pricing. Best Custom Screens is known for its competitive pricing on custom screens, while Home Depot offers competitive rates for in-store products.

Customer Service

Best Custom Screens provides personalized service and expert advice, enhancing the overall customer experience. Home Depot’s customer service experiences can vary, with some customers reporting mixed experiences.

Online vs In-Store Options

Best Custom Screens offers the convenience of online ordering with nationwide shipping. Home Depot provides both in-store purchases and online options, giving customers flexibility in how they shop.

Material Comparison

Best Custom Screens utilizes robust materials to ensure the longevity of their screens. Home Depot’s material quality varies depending on the specific screen product.

Installation Ease

Best Custom Screens streamlines the ordering process with easy online options. Home Depot’s screens may require DIY installation or professional installation services.

Design Options

Best Custom Screens offers extensive design customization, allowing you to choose styles and colors to match your home décor. Home Depot may have limited design options for certain screen products.


Best Custom Screens offers made-to-order screens, which can lead to potential lead times. Home Depot provides in-stock availability for specific screens, ensuring immediate access.


In the ultimate screen showdown between Best Custom Screens and Home Depot, the choice depends on your specific needs. Best Custom Screens shines in customization, quality, and personalized service. On the other hand, Home Depot offers a wide range of screens at competitive prices, catering to diverse customer requirements.

Consider your priorities, from customization to budget, when making your decision. Ultimately, the right choice will enhance your living space and provide the screens that perfectly complement your home.

  1. Best Custom Screens – ↩︎
  2. Wikipedia – ↩︎
  3. Steve Tristan’s Best – ↩︎
  4. The Home Depot – ↩︎

America's Best Screen Door Company - Shielding Your Windows & Doors since 2002